Enjoy 10% OFF your first listing. Receive your personal promo code: Signup Now. Remaining.

Limited time offer. Enjoy 10% OFF your first listing. Receive your personal promo code here: Signup Now


The PropertyNow Blog

Selling House vs Renting it Out: What’s Smarter?

Real estate agents let customers sign contracts

Very few homeowners will live in a single property for their entire life. For most of us, the time will come when we decide to say goodbye to our first home to move into our forever home or embrace a change in lifestyle or scenery.

If you’re in a strong financial position when that time arrives, it can be difficult to know whether you should sell your first home or hang onto it as an investment.

If you’re comparing selling a house vs renting it out, this guide provides an overview of some of the major benefits and downsides associated with each option to help you decide which will be the smarter move.

Renting vs selling pros and cons

Renting it out

The most significant benefit of holding on to your property is the potential to increase your personal wealth from the cash flow you can generate from rental income, as well as the ability to build more equity. If the market value of the property is likely to continue to increase, there’s great potential to benefit on both fronts.

On the other hand, deciding to rent out what was your primary place of residence can have some negative tax implications. While homeowners are exempt from having to pay capital gains tax on the family home, that exemption doesn’t apply to investment properties. You’ll also be liable to pay tax on the rental income.


The major benefit of selling your home is that you can cash in on previous market growth and free up capital for other things. This can mean less financial stress compared to managing the costs associated with owning multiple properties.

However, selling a property which is likely to continue to increase in value can mean you’ll miss out on future capital growth. If you decide to sell and purchase a different investment property, you’ll also be liable to pay stamp duty or land tax on the new property.

The emotional aspect of selling the family home can also be difficult for many homeowners who have years of cherished memories of living in the home.

Selling house vs renting it out: Deciding which option is right for you

Considering the following factors may help you decide which will be the smarter option for you:

  • Whether you’re in the financial position to manage the costs of owning multiple properties.
  • Your stage of life and whether you need to free up capital.
  • The health of the rental market and the likely rental return.
  • The suitability of the home as an investment property.
  • The price you’re likely to achieve if you were to sell.
  • Whether you want to be a landlord.

Ultimately, your decision needs to make financial sense based on your individual circumstances, so it’s always a good idea to seek professional financial advice to fully understand the financial implications of each option.

We can help no matter what you decide to do

Whatever you decide to do, PropertyNow is the easy and affordable way to manage the process yourself.

We can help you sell your property privately to save on exorbitant agent commissions, or if you decide to rent out your property, we also make it easy to advertise the property and start generating rental income.

Sign up with PropertyNow to get started.

Construction plans with drawing tools and House Miniature on bluprint

How to Build a House While Selling Yours

For homeowners looking to upgrade from their first home to their forever home, building allows you to create a home...

A real estate agent with a home model is talking to clients about renting a house

Can You Sell a House but Not the Land?

Selling your home is normally a relatively straightforward process, however, there are some common scenarios where it becomes a little...

Success Stories – Justine from Victoria

"I would definitely tell myself don't hesitate at all, this is a far better way to sell."Read Justine's interview below...

Success Stories – Sally and Brett

"Makes you realise what a numpty you've been in the past letting agents do it for you."Read Sally's interview below...

Success Stories – Vicki, NSW Mid North Coast

"Everyone said I was nuts doing this but the satisfaction I got by getting everything I wanted (price, lengthy settlement...

Senior couple discussing with consultant

How to talk the talk when selling your own home.

Our complete guide on how to talk to buyers in real estate sales. If you’ve been through our resources on...

Gavel justice hammer and wood house on wood background

Online Auctions Virtually Connect Buyers with Private Sellers.

COVID-19 has completely transformed how we buy and sell property. And now real estate transactions are about to change again....

Young couple consult with two real estate agent

Fixed Price Real Estate Agents—What are the advantages of hiring them?

A fixed-fee, online real estate agent like PropertyNow can really offer you great value for money and here’s why. As...

Agent Handing Over the Keys in Front of Business establishment

How to Value a Commercial Property – Top Two Methods

As a commercial property landlord, it can be difficult to decide whether it’s better to sell or lease out your...