Hiring a Real Estate Agent: Will You Get More for Your Home?
Hiring a real estate agent isn’t cheap, so it’s fair to ask the obvious question before you sign: will they get me enough extra to cover what they cost?
Sometimes, yes. Often, nobody can say for sure. This post puts the commission in real dollars, weighs what agents bring for it against what the research shows, and ends with the questions that tell you whether a particular agent is worth it.
The short answer
A good agent can get you a higher price, mainly through pricing and negotiation, but we haven’t found an Australian study that settles whether agents get more than owners, either way. To come out ahead, an agent has to beat what you’d achieve yourself by more than their commission: on an $800,000 home that’s roughly $20,800 more, before GST and marketing costs. Whether a particular agent can do that depends on their track record in your suburb, not on agents in general.
What the commission means in dollars
Most Australian agents charge between 2% and 3% commission, a median of about 2.65% in 2026, and it varies by state and by agent. On an $800,000 home, 2.65% is $21,200. GST usually goes on top, and marketing is often billed separately, whether the home sells or not.
Now compare that with selling privately for a flat fee. With PropertyNow it’s $999, so you’d keep about $20,200 that would otherwise go in commission. For the agent to leave you better off, they’d need to sell for roughly $20,800 more than you would, about 2.6% above your own result. Add GST on the commission and the figure is about $23,000.
That’s the bar. Everything below is about whether an agent is likely to clear it.
What agents bring, and what it’s worth now
Time
An agent takes the calls, books the inspections, runs the opens and chases follow-ups. That’s real work and it has real value, especially if you’re busy, interstate or simply don’t want to do it. It’s a convenience you pay for, though, not something that pushes the price up by itself.
Access to buyers
Agents talk about their buyer lists, and an active local agent may well know someone looking for exactly your type of home. But most buyers now go looking for themselves. Ipsos iris found 15.1 million Australians used homes and property websites and apps in January 2026, which is 68.2% of the online population aged 14 and over. If your home is listed on realestate.com.au and Domain with good photos and a clear ad, those buyers can find it without an agent’s contacts.
Pricing and negotiation skill
This is where a good agent can genuinely add money. They know what recent sales nearby went for, they keep buyers competing, and they don’t flinch at the first offer. Skill varies a lot, though. In NSW, for example, you can start as an assistant agent after five units of the Certificate IV in Real Estate Practice, while a class 2 licence takes the rest of the certificate plus at least 12 months as a registered assistant agent, with supervised logbook tasks signed off along the way. So the person who appraises your home could be brand new or have twenty years behind them.
Both skills can be learned. The comparable sales data agents use is mostly available to you too, and our guides to researching your selling price and negotiating with buyers cover the practical side.
Local reputation
A well-known local agent can bring buyers through the door and give a listing some credibility. That’s worth something in a tight-knit area. Buyers still judge the home and the price, though, not the name on the sign, so reputation helps most when it comes with a strong sales record in your street or suburb.
What does the research say?
We haven’t found an Australian study with a published method that settles whether agents get more than owners. Private sales are a small slice of the market, and the people who choose them aren’t a random sample, so a clean comparison is hard. Two well-known US studies give some clues, with the usual caution that US markets work differently:
- Agents selling their own homes. Levitt and Syverson found homes owned by agents sold for about 3.7% more and stayed on the market about 9.5 days longer than other homes, even after allowing for the homes’ features. Their explanation: an agent gets only a small share of any extra price, so they may nudge clients to accept a lower offer sooner.
- Owners selling online. Hendel, Nevo and Ortalo-Magné compared homes sold through a for sale by owner website in Madison, Wisconsin with agent listings. Prices before commission were no lower for owners, but owner sales took longer and were less likely to sell at all.
Taken together, that’s a fairly balanced picture. An agent’s clearest advantage is speed and certainty of sale, not a higher price (and part of that gap is sellers in less of a hurry choosing to sell privately), while an agent’s incentives don’t always line up with yours. Our private sale vs agent comparison goes through when an agent is the better call.
Questions to ask an agent before you sign
If you’re leaning towards an agent, these questions tell you more than any general claim about agents can:
- How many homes like mine have you sold in this suburb in the last 12 months, and for how much?
- Which recent sales is your price estimate based on? Can I see them?
- What’s your commission rate, does it include GST, and is any of it negotiable?
- What marketing will I pay for, when, and do I pay it if the home doesn’t sell?
- Who will run my inspections and take buyer calls, you or someone junior?
- How long is the agency agreement, and how do I end it if it isn’t working?
The last one matters more than most people expect. If you sign and later change your mind, our guide to agency agreements and switching to a private sale explains how to avoid paying commission twice.
The bottom line
An agent can be worth the money if they’re good at pricing and negotiating, know your suburb well, and you value the time they save you. But a higher price isn’t guaranteed, and it has to be big enough to cover the commission before you’re ahead. If you can price your home to the market, get it onto the major portals and answer buyers promptly, selling privately lets you keep that money. Run the numbers for your own home and ask the hard questions before you decide.
Put a number on it before you sign anything
Work out what an agent’s commission would cost on your place, then compare it with our flat fee of $999 to sell privately.
Frequently asked questions
Do real estate agents get a higher price than private sellers?
Not reliably. We haven’t found Australian data that settles it either way, and a well-known US study found owners selling online got prices no lower before commission, though their homes took longer to sell. A skilled agent can add money through pricing and negotiation; whether yours would depends on their record in your suburb.
How much more does an agent need to get to be worth it?
More than their commission plus any extra costs. On an $800,000 home at a 2.65% commission, the agent would need to achieve roughly $20,800 more than you would selling privately for a $999 flat fee, and more again once GST and marketing are added.
When is hiring a real estate agent worth it?
When you can’t be available for buyers, are selling from interstate or overseas, would rather not negotiate yourself, want an auction, or have a local agent with a strong record selling homes like yours. If the time matters more to you than the money, that’s a fair reason too.
Related stories
- Agent or online agent: a stage-by-stage comparison
- 14 things most real estate agents won’t tell you
- Fixed price real estate agents: the advantages
- How to sell your house fast (without giving it away)
By the PropertyNow team. Last updated November 2026. This article is general information, not financial or legal advice. Commission rates, costs and agency agreement terms vary by state and agent; check the details for your own sale.